Complain about a product or service

Food Industry Accused of Big Tobacco's Bad Habits

Health specialists say two industries share disturbing similarities

By Mark Huffman
ConsumerAffairs.com

March 17, 2009

Food Safety • At Least 2 Deaths Reported in Massive E.Coli Ground Beef Recall • Food Toxin Linked To Liver Cancer • Senate Urged To Pass Food Safety Modernization Act • Consumers Have Little Trust That Food They Buy is Safe and Healthy • Consumers Union Opposes USDA Proposal On Salad Safety • New Food Registry Enables Quick Reporting of Dangerous Products • Nothing Simple about Food Dating, Expiration Dates or 'Use-By' Dates • Feds Announce New Food Safety Strategies • House Passes Food Safety Bill • Feds Seize Kentucky Livestock Kept In "Filthy Conditions" • FDA Tries To Improve Egg Safety • Tainted Dry Milk Recall Continues To Grow • Salmonella Scare Prompts Dairy Recall • Most Consumers Lack Confidence In Food Safety, Survey Says • House Committee Unanimously Passes Food Safety Bill • Food Safety Bill Aired In House • House Committee Moves Forward On Food Safety Legislation • Illinois Meat Packer Recalls 95,898 Pounds Of Beef • Alfalfa Sprouts Linked to Salmonella • Food Safety Results Level Off • Sprouts Recalled Due To Possible Listeria • FDA Warns About Listeria in Salmon • Food Industry Accused of Big Tobacco's Bad Habits • FDA Closes Tortilla Plant • Surface Water May Be Source Of Salmonella • Key Senator Blasts FDA Over Food Safety > • FDA Rolls Out Food Safety Plan • Brits Get Treats, Yanks Get Tricks From Food Companies • Hartz Recalls Rawhide Chips After Possible Salmonella Contamination • Vermont Firm Recalls Possibly-Tainted Ground Beef • Beef Sent to Puerto Rico May Be Contaminated with E. coli • Technology Offers Revolution in Food Safety Testing • Chinese Gorillas Fall Ill as Melamine Scandal Widens • Alfalfa Sprouts Recalled in Salmonella Outbreak • CDC Gives "All Clear" On Salmonella Outbreak • One Death Reported in Oklahoma E. coli Outbreak • Feds Approve Irradiation of Spinach, Lettuce • FDA Issues Warning About Frozen Seafood • Whole Foods Extends Beef Recall • Whole Foods Recalls Fresh Ground Beef • Six New E. coli Cases Reported In Massachusetts --- • More ...

It's an industry accused of exploiting human weakness to push an unhealthy product. Are we talking about the tobacco industry? Well, yes, but some might also say the description applies to the food industry.

At least two public health specialists — Kelly Brownell, director of the Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity at Yale University, and Kenneth Warner, dean of the University of Michigan School of Public Health — see similarities.

They say the food industry of today and the tobacco industry of the 1950s share strategies such as tarring opponents as "fascists," distorting science and insisting that they do not promote overuse of their products.

"The world cannot afford a repeat of the tobacco history, in which industry talks about the moral high ground, but does not occupy it," the authors write in a journal article. "The question is whether they [the food industry] will behave in honorable, health-promoting ways or will sink to the depths occupied by tobacco."

In an interview, Brownell said the two industries are different in many ways, but share a number of strategies:

"One is heavy-duty lobbying; two is paying scientists to produce results that favor industry positions; three is fighting to frame the issue as a matter of personal rather than corporate responsibility and the fourth is funding front groups to do their dirty work," he said.

In their article, which appears in the March issue of The Milbank Quarterly, the co-authors make several suggestions. They say food companies should stop selling unhealthy products in schools and hospitals, end "unwarranted" blaming of people for their actions regarding obesity, stop using celebrities to promote unhealthy food and cease marketing unhealthy foods to children.

The food industry should also reformulate products with healthier ingredients, Brownell said.

"The question is whether you can you count on industry to do this out of goodwill, or will the market just demand these changes because people want better foods?"

Among other points, the article mentions that the American Dietetic Association has taken a stand that there are no good or bad foods, which the authors say is similar to the tobacco industry's early position that "smoking per se was not bad, only 'excess' smoking." The commentary adds that the association's close work with the food industry is an example of the industry's "influential positions in surprising places."

In response, Martin Yadrick, president of the American Dietetic Association, said it is not "valid" to compare food to tobacco, since people need one and not the other.

As for the association's ties to food makers, he said, "Health professionals of all types, especially registered dietitians, need to work with the food industry to ensure a wide variety of healthy food options are available for people. There is no one-size-fits-all definition of 'healthy.'"

Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Share		Follow us on Twitter.